Irony

“Irony? Oh, no, we don’t get that here. You see, people ski topless here whilst smoking dope, so irony is not really a high priority.

“We haven’t had any irony here since, uh, about ’83 when I was the only practitioner of it, and I stopped because I was tired of being stared at.”

So begins the strange courtship of a big-nosed fire chief and a beautiful blonde astronomer.

The words are from the 1987 comedy Roxanne, and the speaker is modern-day Cyrano, CD Bales, aka Steve Martin.

These words spend a little of every day with me: because I am a practitioner who has never tired of being stared at.

Now I think its important to be specific here: because I do not subscribe to every kind of irony. I quite like Socrates’ feigning ignorance to draw someone out.

But leagues away from irony as a tool for cutting down to size, is the New Oxford English Dictionary’s definition: “Irony is a state of affairs or an event that seems deliberately contrary to what one expects and is often amusing as a result.”

Life goes one way, you say it is the opposite. Because, generally, it’s funny.

So CD Bales is met at the door of the fire station by a girl in a pickle. She has locked herself out, minus her clothes. As soon as she knows someone is coming to the door she flees behind a hedge, where she can conduct a conversation in chilly decorum.

“Do you want a coat?” the fire chief asks.

“No, I’d really like to stand out here in the freezing cold”, she retorts.

So he shuts the door and comes out. With some tools, but without the coat. Wrong kind of irony. Hers was designed to deflate.

But he comes out with today’s opener: a most delightful example of the way it isn’t, in the small town in which they live. No jibe intended, just an ironic stream-of-consciousness which ends up with an irony merchant shutting down his practice.

Maddie took this a seven-league-bootstep further this evening when she sat down next to me, doubled up in helpless giggles.

The source of her amusement was one of Phil’s old Ladybird books.

Ladybird readers have helped children learn to read for almost 100 years, all told, and not all of those years, or books, are politically correct.

Leicester printers Wills and Hepworth worked out that printing small books for children would fill the time between their other lucrative print runs – producing material for car manufacturers Austin and Rover.

They are printed in clear, readable sans-serif type, and the books are graded in difficulty. But they do have a few bloopers in their early publications. A is for ass, or armoured train, according to those pioneers of the early reader books.

But they have endured despite their flaws, and old and new print runs are still happening today, out of London and Nottingham.

The book which so amused my daughter is called Danger Men, published in 1970. It attempts to reduce dangerous occupations to the level, and vocabulary, of a six-year-old learning to read.

The first page shows record holder Henri Rochelain suspended high above Monaco Harbour, perched precariously on a tightrope, making a record attempt.

This is a heart stopping moment for all concerned, as he teeters between life and death. No safety net there: for where would one anchor it, in that chic setting?

The writing does not contradict what is happening in this breathtaking picture: it simply understates it to the point of the ridiculous.

It says:

“Can you see the man?

He is in danger.

You can see that he is in danger.

The man is brave.

He is very brave.”

Yes, he is. And I can see that, because he has not opted to take a boat.

Instead he chooses for some insane reason to walk on a piece of string hundreds of feet above a densely populated harbour.

Maddie was helpless with mirth at this irony. And that was just one page.

I won’t go into the gentleman hanging from a rock over white water rapids as his boat careers away; the men on the moon; or even Maddie’s favourite, the bomb disposal expert.

The point is that the simplistic vocabulary is, just as the NOED says, deliberately contrary to what one would expect. And it is extremely funny as a result.

We speak, of course, of the power of the understatement.

This is demonstrated so well by Captain Eric Moody, of an infamous flight from Kuala Lumpur to Perth, who made a level announcement to passengers: “Ladies and Gentlemen, this is your Captain speaking.

“We have a small problem. All four engines have stopped. We are doing our damnedest to get them going again. I trust you are not in too much distress.”

The pilot and his team went without engines for 14 minutes, and were preparing to ditch in the ocean when they cleared volcanic ash which was causing the problem, and landed their 260 passengers and crew in Jakarta.

Irony and understatement run deep in the humour of this little island, and strings of authors speak the language fluently.

Take a lesser known creation of PG Wodehouse: the verbose and deeply ironic Psmith.

Even the name is an irony, a comic twist on the most common surname in England. When he travels to New York, accompanying a cricketing buddy, he is bored. He wishes for a little more action.

And lo, there is a character called Billy Windsor with a boot-faced gangster’s cat in a basket at the next table in the restaurant, who happens to be the editor of an understated little magazine for the faint-hearted called Cosy Moments.

Psmith has found the key to the underbelly of the big city :” I am not half sure, …that Comrade Windsor may not prove to be the genial spirit for whom I have been searching”, he tells his friend.

Events, and Psmith, conspire to bring together these most incongruous elements: a bored English gentleman and a notorious New York gang. A hard-news editorial policy and a cosseted soft readership.

The whole thing is billed as A Great Crisis In New York Journalism. Wodehouse is an ironic virtuoso.

So there’s positive irony, and there’s negative irony.

The positive side can be slapstick , like our Fire Chief.

Sometimes we can only see it in retrospect, like Maddie’s perspective on those first readers, and the heroic Captain’s message.

But to the comic writer, it is almost a second skin. We zip ourselves in, take up our pen, and begin to write like the wind.

All irony is here.

17 thoughts on “Irony

  1. Local slang uses the word irony to describe large metal versions of marbles. My earliest brush with irony was being pelted with one by a brute of a boy called Ralph, who was – I later understood – trying to show me that he fancied me.

    1. Being ardent does that to boys, doesn’t it? One minute they’re jostling with their mates, the next you’re the target. I must remember to have a word with Felix when it comes to his first girlfriend, not to pelt her with irony.

  2. The Irony of War

    The winners win, they’ve made their quest.
    The winners lose, their dead to rest.

    The losers can win too is the rule,
    no more deaths from the horrid duel.

    The single one who can truly win
    is Mr Death with skeletal grin.

  3. This was such a delicious read. Hours of combing and reading library books and thrift store childrens books has made me appreciative of its subtle irony. The childrens book author can’t be too flashy or smart…the words not too smart. But the concept surprisingly if it tailors around death and other big life theories seems to be a check point for the little missus.

    Its like writing a poem, writing for children.
    Action verbs rule. Long sentences are shunned. Simplicity in a complex thought. A .

    With all these rules, the author has to find some reprieve. The irony. Like writing a news piece in those early 20s -throw in a cliche, pair a high class verb with a cheap adjective. It gets published. Ah, yes the nerdiness of writers and how they find their jolies. Dare I mention the use of colons and hyphenated words?

    (sorry for the tangent)

    1. Your tangents are always welcome, UE 🙂 Writing for children is, indeed, notoriously difficult to do well. I suspect you are very good at it indeed. And I think children’s books have come a long way since 1970…

  4. Paraphrasing from a book I read recently, irony is defined what a man wants to have happening to him, and what actually does happen to him. Good quote, I think. Good post, too.

  5. I remember the Ladybird books. My grandmother gave me a whole box of them that she had used with her children. They always made me giggle, too, if I recall correctly.

  6. Irony is a funny thing – I like it, use it perhaps more than I’m aware of (when I’m not painstakingly monitoring my speech so as not to offend :)). The problem is, people tend to take me seriously when I’m not… I love the British sense of humour, so much of it in older movies and TV series I can watch and watch again.

  7. I remember this scene so well from Roxanne. Remember laughing at it, as well as other lines as the story plays out, Steve Martin’s delivery so, well, so ironic. What a great post, Kate. A fun lit on irony as I end my day here after a fun book discussion and ride home in yet more snow. Ahhhhh.

Leave a reply to Kristine Cancel reply